Confident women less influential than male colleagues

Confident high-performing women are only influential at the workplace if they are also perceived as “nurturing”.

What’s wrong with being confident? Nothing at all – unless you’re a woman in the workplace, that is.

A new research study from business school INSEAD indicates self-confidence in the office is more rewarding for men than women.

The study, which analysed the judgements of 236 computer engineers at a multinational software company, found that the correlation between confidence and influence was straightforward for a man: the better he performs, the more self-confident he is perceived as being, and the greater the influence he wields in the workplace.

High-performing and confident women, on the other hand, were only considered influential by peers and supervisors if those traits were partnered with “nurturing” behaviour (e.g. “I care about benefiting others through  my work”).

The study, led by INSEAD Associate Professor of Decision Sciences Natalia Karelaia, measured and analysed job performance, “prosocial orientation” (one’s level of concern for others’ welfare), self-confidence, and organisation influence to draw the above results.

“For companies that care about gender equality, if being a good organisational citizen and helping others is a requirement, it should be so for men and women equally,” said Professor Karelaia.

“Organisations should be willing to question the assumptions of meritocracy. It is obvious that women are not accepted on their merits alone, so supervisors should take these findings into account when appraising the performance of their female staff,” she added.

Appearing self-confident and getting credit for it: Why it may be easier for men than women to gain influence at work

Click here for more Diversity News Click here for more Leadership News Click here for more Talent Management News
Diversity and inclusion: more than checking the box
HRM Asia - 20 Jun 2018
HR must continue to enact HR policies that eliminate real and perceived social differences.
P&G’s efforts against workplace harassment, bullying, and discrimination
- 19 Jun 2018
With #MeToo throwing light on workplace harassment, it has become more important than ever for companies to call out clear standards for conduct.
Corporate LGBT advocacy: An ongoing fight
HRM Asia - 24 May 2018
Why companies must do their part to ensure that LGBT rights do not go in reverse.
How analytics raised engagement levels at Takeda Pharmaceutical
- 17 May 2018
HR Insider preview: Takeda's HR consolidation has been an integral part of the company's journey to going global.
Uncovering the gender pay gap
HRM Asia - 04 May 2018
A new study has identified that the real reason for the gender pay gap is the lack of women in higher-paying roles.
Standard Chartered's new staff-centric global brand campaign
Kelvin Ong - 02 May 2018
Some 85,000 employees gave their insights during the design process of the new marketing campaign.