Overqualification can strain family life, or free it up

Being overqualified leaves some employees anxious and drained at home, and gives others more time for family. What sets them apart is which of the two they value more.

Employees with more skills than their jobs require have long been something of a puzzle for employers. They can be bored, frustrated and disengaged in roles that fail to stretch them, yet, given the right conditions, they can also be among an organisation’s strongest performers.

New research co-authored by Associate Professor Alex Luksyte of The University of Western Australia (UWA) Business School carries that question out of the office and into the home, asking whether being overqualified makes work and family life harder or easier to reconcile. The answer, it turns out, depends largely on which of the two an employee values more.

Published in The International Journal of Human Resource Management, the research drew on two studies of employees in Chinese banking and other industries, conducted with colleagues from Beihang University and Tsinghua University. Overqualified employees who valued work above family reported more anxiety about their career development, along with more strain-based work-family conflict, where they were too worn out to take part in family activities and responsibilities. Those who valued family above work reported less time-based conflict.

Dr Luksyte, who has studied overqualification since her PhD, says the research started from two expectations that pointed in opposite directions.

Dr Alex Luksyte, Associate Professor. The University of Western Australia

“On the one hand, we thought that living with an overqualified partner could be really detrimental to family life, because overqualified people may bring their frustration, boredom and dissatisfaction to their family lives, and these negative attitudes can spill over,” she tells HRM Asia.

“But we also thought that one of the best predictors of work-family conflict is work overload. When people are exhausted at work, they bring that tiredness home. Interestingly, overqualified employees are unlikely to experience work overload, because they have more knowledge, skills and abilities than their jobs require. They can actually experience underload, which means that when they come home, they are not tired, and they may have time and energy for their family lives.”

Because work-family conflict describes two parts of life pulling against each other, the team looked for something that ties them together. That led them to work and family centrality, which refers to how much weight a person places on each.

Values of that kind may seem too personal for a manager to read. Dr Luksyte suggests they are often more visible than they appear.

“Usually employees behave consistently with their values,” she says. “And this is particularly true in organisations that foster a culture in which employees feel free and psychologically safe to enact their work and family values.”

What managers do with that understanding should differ between the two groups. For overqualified employees who put work first, the research points to career anxiety as the source of the strain, and Dr Luksyte says addressing that anxiety directly could help.

“Managers who sense that for these employees work is more important than family may offer additional professional development opportunities,” she says. “They may offer mentoring opportunities so that these employees could serve as mentors for their peers, or interesting projects that challenge them and let them direct their underutilised qualifications. In doing so, they may become less anxious about their career development.”

Those who put family first need something else entirely. Some may have taken a role below their capabilities on purpose and use the spare capacity to give more of themselves at home.

“For these employees, it’s important to offer them more work flexibility, so that they can perform their core responsibilities quickly and with relative ease and have more time for their families,” Dr Luksyte says. “In doing so, they will experience less work-family conflict, but they will also be more committed and loyal to their organisations.”

Whether someone chooses to be overqualified matters too. Drawing on wider research, Dr Luksyte notes that people who deliberately take such roles to make room for family, hobbies or volunteering tend to perform well and are unlikely to experience much work-family conflict.

The picture shifts when the choice is not theirs, whether because suitable jobs are scarce or because a partner’s relocation left few options.

READ MORE: What raising a child taught a CEO about leading

“In this case, being overqualified may feel like being trapped in a job,” she says. “And if these employees feel stuck, particularly if they don’t see the situation changing or feel it may be permanent, their negative job attitudes and even counterproductive work behaviours may last.”

For employers, she says, the task is to recognise what these employees bring to the table.

“They have more education, skills, abilities and qualifications than their jobs need, which is why they could potentially make a lot of positive contributions,” she concludes. “Organisations need to think about how to utilise that potential, so that these employees are not just productive, motivated and engaged, but have good family lives as well.”

Share this articles!

Latest Topics

More from HRM Asia

Promoted for results, left to figure out the rest

In the second of two pieces, Gwen Lockington, Founder and Principal of Lockington People and Advisory, explains why management capability remains a persistent gap, and what flatter structures and AI now ask of the managers who remain.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Stay updated with the latest HR insights and events,
delivered right to your inbox.

Sponsorship Opportunity

Get in touch to find out more about sponsorship and exhibition opportunities.