Promoted for results, left to figure out the rest
- Josephine Tan
- Topics: Features, Home Page - Features, Leadership, Talent Management
Management capability matters regardless of company size, industry, growth ambitions or location, says Gwen Lockington, Founder and Principal of Lockington People and Advisory. In her view, the reason it so often falls short also has little to do with any of those factors.
“The gap persists because organisations treat management as a secondary task rather than a distinct role,” she says. “People are selected for technical results, handed a team, and left to figure it out. Most managers carry individual targets alongside undefined management responsibilities, flying blind on what good leadership looks like.”
Gallup’s data points to a growing strain. Its State of the Global Workplace 2026 report found that global managers fell from 31% in 2022 to 22% in 2025. Managers once enjoyed what Gallup calls an “engagement premium” over the people they lead, but they are increasingly only as engaged as their teams. Many, Gallup notes, have not received the training they need to coach teams and individuals towards high performance.
Lockington points to further pressures. “Recent restructuring has expanded spans of control while reducing peer support,” she says. “Long hours, lean teams, and top-down hierarchies compound the pressure.”
In Hong Kong, where Lockington is based, Gallup found that just 5% of employees were engaged at work in 2025, against an East Asia average of 18%.
“Organisations have asked managers to absorb every wave of change, from hybrid work to AI, without investing in them at a matching pace,” she says. “Yet managers dictate the employee experience.”
Some organisations have found a way through. Within the best-practice organisations Gallup studies, 79% of managers are engaged, nearly four times the global average.
Fewer layers, wider spans
The structures managers work within are also changing. In 2024, Gartner predicted that through 2026, 20% of organisations would use AI to flatten their organisational structure, eliminating more than half of current middle management positions.
For Lockington, that changes what the job involves.
“As AI absorbs routine tasks, managers shoulder more human-centric responsibilities: coaching, providing context, resolving conflict, and decision-making,” she says. “While exciting, large spans of control make this daunting. A manager overseeing 20 direct reports cannot coach effectively.”
Gallup’s research points in the same way. Its study of managers in the US found that engagement declines with larger spans of control, although manager talent and training can offset the effect.
There is a longer-term cost as well. Losing middle management layers, Lockington says, “removes the vital training ground where future senior leaders cut their teeth.”
For those who remain, she says, the role demands “active coaches who can connect strategy to daily execution, prioritise time with people, and lead effectively across both hybrid and in-person environments.”
More than a training course
Much of this begins at the move into management. New managers, Lockington explains, must shift their identity from individual production to enabling others. That means learning to coach instead of doing the work themselves, and redefining their relationships with former peers.
When that transition fails, she looks beyond the individual.
“The transition fails when the surrounding ecosystem lacks support: clear expectations, training, coaching, and accountability,” she says. “Training sets a baseline, but success requires ongoing mentoring, peer communities, and accountability tied directly to targets and bonuses.”
Who steps into management matters too. “Organisations must offer alternative career progression paths so managing people is not the only route up,” Lockington says. “In Hong Kong, where titles signal status, credible alternative tracks ensure the right people step into management.”
When no one owns it
If managers need more support, someone has to own it. Lockington is clear about who that should be.
“Responsibility sits with line leadership, the manager’s direct manager, who sets expectations and enforces accountability, supported by HR for capability design and IT for seamless tools.”
Without that ownership, the effects spread. “Change stalls, employees drift to unapproved tools, and managers remain silent while their teams read that silence as scepticism,” she says.
AI adoption shows that is at stake. In a 2025 Gallup survey of employees in the US, 28% of those whose organisations had begun implementing AI strongly agreed that their manager actively supported their team’s use of it. Compared with colleagues who did not strongly agree, those employees were twice as likely to use AI a few times a week or more, and 6.5 times as likely to strongly agree that their organisation’s AI tools are useful for their work.
“In Hong Kong, this is compounded by employees using VPNs or regional workaround to access tools,” Lockington adds.
She points to Prosci’s change management research, which she says shows that change only sticks when sponsors are active and visible, and frontline managers are fully equipped to coach their teams through the transition.”
“AI adoption requires the exact same foundation support.”


