Own data, not benchmarks: What holds up in a board conversation on wellbeing
- Josephine Tan
“Health must always come first, and productivity will naturally follow.” – Kenneth Tan, Chief Corporate Solutions Officer at AIA Singapore
Ask a boardroom whether workforce health is important, and the answer is now almost unanimous. AIA’s Corporate Wellness Study found that 99% of employers and 95% of employees regard corporate wellness programmes as essential to the workplace. Employers can also explain why they run them: to reduce employee stress (78%), improve productivity (62%) and lift morale (46%).
What happens after the programme is launched is a different matter. The same study found that 54% of providers do not collect feedback or evaluate the impact of the programmes they already run.
That gap – broad agreement in principle, thin evidence on outcomes – is where the case for workplace wellbeing tends to fall apart when it reaches a CFO or a board, according to Kenneth Tan, Chief Corporate Solutions Officer at AIA Singapore. Speaking with HRM Asia following the inaugural AIA Healthcare Summit, where he argued that wellbeing should be treated as a strategic investment rather than a discretionary perk, Tan says the framing an HR leader chooses often decides the outcome before the numbers are examined.
“Conversations with CFOs and board members typically stall when wellbeing is presented as a standalone ‘programme’ or HR initiative rather than a core business driver,” he says. C-suite leaders work in the language of business outcomes, he adds, so the task is to show how the initiative connects to productivity, retention, engagement and performance, and where it sits in the wider picture.
The question executives should be asking, in his view, is not whether the organisation can afford to invest in wellbeing, but how that investment strengthens workforce capability, resilience and long-term business performance.
What survives scrutiny
On the evidence itself, Tan draws a distinction that has practical consequences for how HR teams prepare. Industry research and benchmark studies provide useful context, he says, but they rarely convince a board.
“What often holds up under board-level scrutiny is organisation-specific data,” he says. “Decision-makers are typically more persuaded by evidence showing how wellbeing indicators correlate with business outcomes within their own workforce.”
That places a burden on internal measurement that many organisations are not currently carrying – which returns to the 54% who collect no feedback at all. Tan describes the absence of impact evaluation as a leadership blind spot, and one that leaves HR arguing from someone else’s numbers.
His prescription is to shift away from activity metrics. Participation rates and headcount, he says, tell leaders how many people turned up, not what changed. A dashboard worth putting in front of a board would include engagement rates, the benefits employees use, and how health improvement trends evolve over time, giving what he calls a 360-degree view of how workforce wellbeing is driving a more resilient business.
Success, in his framing, should be measured by whether initiatives reduce burnout, improve retention, strengthen engagement and support sustainable performance.
AIA’s own approach separates the two problems. Getting employees to take part comes first, through modular activities across the different pillars of health; personal accountability and habit formation follow, with progress tracked through exercise days logged, health screenings completed and measured health improvement. Tan’s underlying position is that the sequence matters more than the tooling: “Health must come first, and productivity will naturally follow along, when employees are physically, mentally, socially, and financially resilient.”
One framework, many markets
For HR leaders running a strategy across several Asia-Pacific markets – where ageing is arriving at very different speeds, and where AIA operates in 18 markets – Tan’s advice is to separate what should be held in common from what must be built locally.
What travels, he says, is a common corporate framework built around holistic health, with local teams given room to adapt. What does not travel is the delivery: “What must be rebuilt locally are specific engagement tactics and messaging, as health stereotypes, attitudes towards mental health, and financial priorities vary across different markets.”
The implication for regional HR is that a programme catalogue can be shared while communications, incentives and framing cannot – a distinction that is easy to state and, in practice, where much regional rollout runs into difficulties.
Five years out
Asked what would indicate that employers had genuinely changed how they think about workforce health, rather than what they offer, Tan pointed to four signals.
The first is integration: health embedded in how work is designed and managed, not bolted on beside it. The second is a move from reactive support to prevention, which he defined in terms of sustainable workloads, supportive leadership, effective team environments and healthy ways of working – the conditions of the job itself, in other words, rather than the services offered to compensate for them.
The third is ownership. “Progress would also be evident if workforce health became a shared leadership responsibility rather than something owned exclusively by HR or wellbeing teams,” he says. The fourth is evaluation, closing the loop on the 54% finding: organisations should systematically collect feedback and assess impact rather than track participation.
READ MORE: Ten years of poor health, and the workplace in the middle of it
Tan also expects employers to treat physical, mental, social and financial wellbeing as interconnected, and to weigh long-term workforce health and employability alongside short-term productivity.
Much of that describes governance more than benefits design, which aligns with the argument he made at the summit. It also sets a higher bar than most wellbeing reporting currently meets. Based on the evidence from AIA’s own study, the first move for many employers is narrower and less strategic than any of them: finding out whether what they already run is working.


